Brighton and Hove Albion are making headlines not for their goalscorers, but for their goalkeepers – or rather, the constant rotation between them. Manager Roberto de Zerbi has taken a unique approach, utilizing both Jason Steele and Robert Sanchez’s understudy, Bart Verbruggen, throughout the 2023-24 season. This strategy has resulted in a new Premier League record – 17 goalkeeper changes – surpassing the previous record of 14 set by Manchester United in 2000-01.
While Arsenal were initially expected to be the team experimenting with a rotating goalkeeper system, Brighton has become the unlikely pioneer. Unlike Manchester United’s situation, where injuries forced their hand, de Zerbi’s decision appears tactical. This raises the question: can this unconventional approach be a recipe for success in the Premier League?
Traditionally, stability in goal has been considered vital. A consistent goalkeeper develops a rhythm and builds a strong understanding with the backline, leading to a more organized defense. However, de Zerbi’s strategy suggests he might prioritize keeping both goalkeepers sharp and motivated.
There could be some merit to this approach. Offering playing time allows both Steele and Verbruggen to gain valuable experience, potentially pushing each other to improve. Additionally, it could prevent complacency from setting in if one goalkeeper feels assured of their starting position.
However, there are also potential drawbacks. Frequent changes could disrupt the defensive unit’s cohesion, as the backline needs to adapt to slight variations in communication and playing style between the goalkeepers. Additionally, a lack of consistent playing time might hinder a goalkeeper’s individual development, making it difficult to find their best form.
The jury is still out on whether de Zerbi’s gamble will pay off. Brighton currently sits comfortably mid-table, suggesting the strategy hasn’t necessarily hurt them. However, if they aspire to challenge for European spots or the coveted top four, the goalkeeping situation might need to be reevaluated.
